Criticism as Asynchronous Collaboration: An Example from Social Science Research

Y

14

Institute of Education Sciences (ED)
Office of Naval Research (ONR) (DOD)

R305D190048

Criticism; Political Science; Social Science Research; Authors; Collaborative Writing; Writing for Publication; Statistical Analysis; Data Use; Statistical Significance; Reader Response

I discuss a published paper in political science that made a claim that aroused skepticism. The reanalysis is an example of how we, as consumers as well as producers of science, can engage with published work. This can be viewed as a sort of collaboration performed implicitly between the authors of a published paper and later researchers who want to understand or use the published work. [This paper was published in "Stat."]

As Provided

Yes

2023

ED634352